A commenter on my post “Facing the Facts” yesterday said that she is learning yoga from books and tapes but that she is “still somewhat self conscious as I’m a bit ’round’ and embarrassed to go to a class with so many thin and very flexible people.”
I’ve been there. In fact, I still am there. When I walked into my first yoga class, I was significantly overweight — about 55 pounds or so. Today I can still count on often being the heaviest yogini in the room as I have about 20-25 pounds left to lose. I’m also tall and I come from good Kansas farming stock, so I know I will never be a teeny yogini. Muscular and powerful, yes. Skinny and lithe, no. My people lift bales of hay, stick their arms into birthing cows, and can mountains of tomatoes. My grandma was plump and round, but under the soft layer she had biceps hard as rocks. I once saw her chop the head off a bullsnake with a single blow of her shovel.
I know how it is to feel like you’re the big lumbering brute in the room, but I can guarantee that once you get your gumption up to go to a class, it will be worth it. At least it was for me. I feel nothing but admiration and compassion for the heavier folks who keep showing up. I know what it takes to come to class when you’re feeling, well, big and clumsy and stiff.
It may take a while to build enough confidence to go to a class and while you’re in that confidence-building stage, studying yoga through books and tapes and tapes can be very helpful. When you’re ready, I think you’ll find that most yoga teachers are very welcoming and compassionate souls and that there are people of all shapes and sizes in most yoga classes. If you feel uncomfortable or criticized, vote with your feet and find another class or teacher.
I feel sad when I hear people say that they feel they have to be A. thinner, B. more flexible, or C. able to do X-Asana before attending a yoga class. I’ve said it before on this blog, but yoga is for everybody! The only prerequisite is a willingness to learn and an open mind (not open hips!). This idea that you have to be somehow “better” before you go to a yoga class is just another one of those self-defeating attitudes, a variation on that self-critical radio station in your head (the writer Anne Lamott calls it “KFKD” – you can figure out what FKD stands for!). I can honestly say that the only criticism I have ever felt in a yoga class has come directly from good ol’ me. I’m sure my teachers must have thought, while trying to help me bind in Marichyasana C, “If she would just lose a few pounds and shrink the belly, she’d be able to do this pose herself.” All of them have had the grace not to say that to me!
Okay, so you’re ready to venture out to a class. Maybe you’re not at your ideal weight yet, but you’re ready. Now, what do you wear? When I first started yoga, I wore baggy t-shirts over loose exercise pants. I would tuck the front hem of the t-shirt into my waistband so as not to blind everyone by flashing my lily-white belly during Downward Dog. Don’t worry about being a fashionista, just be comfortable. A slightly fitted t-shirt is less cumbersome than a huge baggy one. Now I wear a yoga camisole top that doesn’t ride up and a pair of yoga pants (cropped pants or bootcut long pants). The only disadvantage to this outfit is that when I’m in Shoulderstand, I’m confronted with my lovely belly rolls, a reminder of how far I have yet to go.
The thing is, I don’t think anyone is ever completely satisfied with her body. I betcha that Miss Teeny Yogini up there in the front row is thinking about the three pounds she gained over vacation, or how she’s up to a size 4 instead of a 2! I know! It’s crazy! (If I ever fit into a size 4, I will immediately keel over dead from shock.) But we all have our body image problems, and I’m pretty sure that all of those thin, flexible folks are far too busy thinking about their own issues to give more than a passing thought to the circumference of your thighs. They are more preoccupied with binding their wrists in Marichyasana D than noticing that you couldn’t get your palms flat on the floor in a standing forward bend. As my grandpa used to say, “You wouldn’t worry so much about what people thought of you if you knew how little they did.”
When you are ready, I hope you will venture out there to the yoga studio. The group energy you get from a class can be invigorating, and there are lots of great teachers out there who will inspire you to take your practice further. Will yoga help you lose weight? There is a lot of debate on that in the yoga world. In my own experience, yes, the combination of a vigorous ashtanga practice and the positive changes it has inspired in my life has helped me lose weight. As I’ve continued to practice, I’ve found that I am more aware of how certain foods make me feel energized and healthy, and how others make me feel sluggish. I’ve found that certain foods, like meat or alcohol, just don’t appeal to me as much as they used to. I know that practicing ashtanga ramps up my metabolism and energy levels. The combination of these factors has led me to lose about 30 pounds in the past several years; it’s been a slow process, but in my experience, gradual change sticks!
So am I glad I ignored that little voice in my head telling me I was too chubby and uncoordinated to go to a yoga class? You bet I am. Guess what? No matter you weigh, no matter how flexible you are, there will always be someone out there who is thinner, more flexible, and possibly even nicer and more enlightened than you. Why should those people have all the fun?
September 13, 2006 at 6:14 pm
I hear you. And trust me – many many people who you would consider teeny have serious body issues, whether all the time, or just some of the time. And EVERYONE over the age of 25 has some “foldage” in shoulderstand. Even me – and I had a tummy tuck last year. It’ just too little collagen and too much gravity!
September 13, 2006 at 8:32 pm
I feel the same way too. I’m round, and short. always wish to have longer limbs ( which I can’t have no matter what!!) or skinnier.
Trying to get that thoughts out, having fun during the practice and trying to build up my strength and stamina. Yoga can help us lose weight, i feel that I lost my apetite a little bit and eat a little less after a big good practice. Those bandhas!! I’m a bit of a mood-eater, getting compulsive when stress. But yeah that’s what I found.
September 13, 2006 at 8:32 pm
Oh, absolutely. Many of those people are small precisely *because* they have body issues!
I can’t see anyone else’s tummy when I’m in shoulderstand, so I’ll take your word for it!
September 13, 2006 at 9:06 pm
I’m not round, really, just average, but I have always felt anxious about taking a class because I am extremely stiff. I have this deep embarrassment about not being able to reach down or out, and touch my toes. When I do any type of bend I can go no further than my upper shins, sometimes I have to stay at my knees.
All of this is to say that, well, I am starting to get over myself and posts like this one really help. Thanks!
September 13, 2006 at 10:19 pm
Thank you so much for your response!
I’m the one who wrote that comment, and appreciate the encouragement.
I’ve only just begun (no cheesy music in the background!)
but already I’ve seen improvement after just a couple of weeks.
When I started I could not balance at all in “tree pose” (sorry, I still don’t know the correct sanskrit word for it), now my focus has improved and I am able to.
I love it when I start sweating after a few sun salutations. I imagine it’s like I’m being juiced with all the bad going out and the good coming in with each breath.
I know the word for me is “modify” for now but if I keep going the way I am the asanas will come, my confidence will build and I’ll soon be at a local shala.
Thank you again!
September 14, 2006 at 7:34 am
loving this whole conversation. i went to three studios (i’ve never heard “shala” but i’m assuming it’s a close parallel) before i felt comfortable enough to come back. being in a large class helps immensely. and even the smaller people have rolls in shoulderstand – i’m slightly embarrassed to admit it, but yeah, i’ve looked.
what i try to remember is something kest says during the first power yoga video: “we’re all going to fall in life. fall with awareness and acceptance.” for me, what this means is that you hit the floor much more gracefully (and quietly) if you know it’s coming than if you just drop suddenly out of a pose. this is a huge help to the ego (like, “i meant to do that!”)
also a very timely conversation for me – there’s a three-day workshop next weekend that will be packed and full of advanced yogis. i’m alternately excited and terrified. fun stuff.
September 14, 2006 at 8:34 am
Kansas – where at? My wife is from there too! How funny.
September 14, 2006 at 8:51 am
My family is from the boonies west of Wichita. I was born in Wichita but haven’t lived in Kansas since I was nine.
“Shala” is basically a yoga studio — I’ve heard it in reference to ashtanga studios. I don’t know if the other yoga traditions use the word or not.
September 14, 2006 at 10:19 am
Another encouragement to my fellow “round ones”
I’ve also noticed an almost effortless gravitation towards more wholesome (organic) foods, balanced meals, manageable amounts.
I think that continuing to practice does it’s work more than outwardly, but even to cellular, emotional, mental level. A wonder to watch!
September 14, 2006 at 10:55 am
Well said yogamum!
September 14, 2006 at 5:22 pm
Micki, you’re absolutely right! That’s how it has worked out for me as well.
September 14, 2006 at 7:28 pm
Yogamum, great post. I thought I was the only yogini on earth to have to look at her stomach rolls in shoulderstand, with disgust. I am slim by American standards, but fat by yogini standards. Older yoginis who have given birth to children are at a disadvantage in ashtanga, don’t you think? Once a woman has given birth, she no longer has a flat ab. Mari C & D will be compromised. Young superthin yoginis, and some teachers, will look at you with scorn. In my experience.
September 14, 2006 at 7:41 pm
I’m another one who was pretty overweight when I first started doing ashtanga. But once I started I stopped feeling self-conscious about my weight – except in the dreaded shoulderstand! (Dreaded because or the multiple tummy rolls!)
I did lose a bit of weight from doing ashtanga, but eventually (some years down the track) I was motivated to really do something about my weight, mostly because I could not bind in poses like any of the marichyasanas. I’d been stuck there for about 2 years with no progress it seemed.
And now, 13 months later I’ve lost 27-28 kilos and can do the first 2 marichyasanas, and one side of C! I’m happy with my weight now (well mostly!), though I do still have a faint tummy roll in shoulderstand …
And whether you or anyone loses weight or not, I think it’s wonderful to do yoga, and I’m so glad I was able to push myself into a class all those years ago.
September 14, 2006 at 8:48 pm
Suzie — I have seen some moms with flat abs, but I have no clue how they managed that! I personally haven’t seen any scornful looks, but I live in the ‘burbs and most of the women populating the classes I’ve taken are in their 30’s and up. It’s probably different in fashionable urban areas!
Susie — wow, 28 kilos (I am metrically-challenged but that’s over 60 pounds, right?)! Good for you! And good for you for sticking with the practice all these years.
September 15, 2006 at 9:41 am
From the bottom of my heart and soul, I thank you for this post. It took me a while to muster up the courage to take an Ashtanga class at a studio, with my somewhat matronly figure. I thought that I’d first get back to my pre-pregnancy weight, and then take classes. But after taking classes, I can see a lot of benefits that I didn’t really get from videos and books at home. Anyhow, I still find myself avoiding classes when I feel like my diet isn’t going well, or if my home practice is sliding. Actually, I was thinking of skipping my led class this Saturday, and this post has led me to rethink that.
September 15, 2006 at 10:32 am
Caroline, sometimes I think the best time to go to a led class is precisely when you are feeling a little iffy about your practice (caveat: assuming you like the teacher!) because you might learn something that helps you ramp things up a little bit, or you might get a little jolt of that group energy. Obviously this only works if the class has a generally good vibe!
September 16, 2006 at 2:04 am
I’m joining in on this topic a bit late. It’s always great to hear about people beginning yoga. Keep trying! Even after seven years of practice, I still feel a bit intimidated by other yogis–like, I easily fall into padahastasana yet I don’t think I will ever be able to do a proper shoulder stand or halasana (and forget about binding!). It’s all about modifying and focusing only on what goes on on your mat (easier said than done). Yoga has definitely taught me to accept, honour, and love my body as it is–and its limitations. It’s an on-going process and I am fortunate to have had a couple of teachers who have helped and inspired me along the way. So my advice to beginners echoes yogamum–shop around and find a teacher and group that you like. (I actually go to different teachers depending on my mood.) And keep reading fab yoga blogs like this one!
March 11, 2008 at 3:59 am
Thank you thank you thank you thank you so VERY much for this post! I’m 5 ft 10 and weigh 180lbs (a heck of a lot better than the 225 I used to weigh, I think I’ve done my sums right, I was 16 stone 1lb, a Brit here), and feel like a huge lumbering giant in class! I’m lucky that I am v flexible, but it’s really hard to feel so fat in class, even though i’ve already lost a considerable amount of weight. I just keep hoping that if I keep on practicing 4-5 times a week, and running and cycling, eventually the extra 28 lbs will come off and I’ll start feeling better about myself. Mind you, i find that yoga helps you to feel better about your body and therefore the weight comes off more easily.
What I’ve found helps me is to just to try and really focus on myself when practicing and not look at others. Not always easy when there is someone who’s thighs are thinner than my calves right opposite, but I keep trying this approach anyway!